New Data Show Radiation Fears Should Not Deter Women from Mammography Screening

The risk of radiation-induced breast cancer from mammography screening is small in comparison to the benefit of expected lives saved, according to new data.

The study's findings appeared online in November 2010 and in the January 2010 issue of the journal Radiology. "Recently, there have been reports in the press focusing on the potential radiation risk from mammography, particularly as used for periodic screening,” said the study's lead author, Martin J. Yaffe, PhD, senior scientist in imaging research at Sunnybrook Health Sciences Center (Toronto, Canada), and professor in the departments of medical biophysics and medical imaging at the University of Toronto (Canada). "Our study shows that the risk of cancer associated with routine screening in women age 40 and over is very low, especially when compared to the benefits associated with early detection.”

Dr. Yaffe and his colleague, James G. Mainprize, PhD, developed a model for estimating the risk of radiation-induced breast cancer following exposure of the breast to ionizing radiation from various screening mammography scenarios and estimated the potential number of breast tumors, fatal breast cancers, and years of life lost attributable to mammography screening.

Using a radiation dose estimate of 3.7 mGy, which is typical for digital mammography, and a cohort of 100,000 women, the researchers applied the risk model to predict the number of radiation-induced breast cancers attributable to a single examination and then extended the model to various screening scenarios beginning and ending at different ages. The study's findings revealed that in 100,000 women, each receiving a dose of 3.7 mGy to both breasts, annual screening from age 40 to 55 years and biennial screening thereafter to age 74 years would result in 86 radiation-induced tumors, including 11 fatal cancers, and 136 life years lost.

Conversely, for the same cohort it was estimated that 497 lives and 10,670 life years would be saved by earlier detection. "The predicted risk of radiation-induced breast cancer from mammography screening is low in terms of the numbers of cancers induced, the number of potential deaths, and the number of years of life lost,” Dr. Yaffe said. "For women over 40, the expected benefits afforded by routine screening in terms of lives saved or years of life saved greatly exceed this risk. For these women, radiation risk should not be a deterrent from screening.”

Related Links:
University of Toronto